Patreon adult content policy and subscription fatigue
Blog Post Written By: Melrose Michaels
In 2013 I launched a subscription pay site under my first stage name, and in its best month it never made more than $2,000. I ran it for two years before letting it go. Almost a decade later OnlyFans did essentially the same thing and became a household name, so my model was fine even though the timing was the problem.
Timing is really just a question of what consumers are willing to do in a given year, which is why I have been thinking about that site all week. Patreon shipped around thirty new features on August 20 and two of them reached pages marked 18+.
I also spent this year canceling almost every subscription I personally pay for, which is a harder thing to sit with when subscriptions are how I make a living.
What Patreon actually did on August 20th
Native Video and a short form clipping tool called Quips are now rolling out to creators whose pages are marked 18+, and I watched that get reported as Patreon opening its doors to adult creators. Two tools became available to pages that already existed under a label that already existed. What Patreon permits you to post did not move at all.
I went and read the current community guidelines myself before filming, and the line is drawn where it has been. Photorealistic depictions of real people having sex are still banned outright regardless of who posts them or how the page is labeled. What sits inside the 18+ lane is animated or illustrated nudity, non-explicit intimate content, sexual education without depictions and mature themes inside a narrative, all behind a paywall and none of it in your profile picture or banner.
None of this arrived out of nowhere and the groundwork has been public for months. Patreon has been rewriting its adult content policy for the better part of a year, and back in March it renamed the section that used to be called sexually gratifying works to adult and 18+ works. That reads like a wording change until you sit with it, because it moves the whole category away from a term treating adult content as inherently shameful and toward a plain label. The feature rollout this week is the second half of that process rather than a new position.
What I found when I audited my own bank statements
At the beginning of this year I sat down with every bank statement and went through them properly, because the math was not adding up and I could not keep running on a picture I had stopped checking.
What they told me was that I had been paying for things I had forgotten existed. I cancelled almost all of it, on the personal side and the business side both, and I now watch my best friend's Disney+ and HBO like a college student with zero shame about it. On the business side I cut tools and software while owning a software company, which is its own kind of funny.
I expected the audit to feel like loss and it felt like clarity instead. I get into the whole thing in this week's newsletter, including the cut I made in the middle of the year that carried real weight and did not stop carrying it just because it was the right call.
Why I think the subscription model has peaked
Subscription fatigue is a consumer problem happening across every market at once, and our industry does not get an exemption from consumer behavior because our product is different. That is the part I do not hear said out loud very often, and I understand why, because it sounds like bad news for the model most of us built on.
The pattern I am tracking inside CEO Society and in my own numbers does not look like a crisis from the outside. Fans are not canceling dramatically all at once in a way that would announce itself. Fans are not subscribing in the first place, free trials that used to convert are sitting unused, and rebills that ran for two years are getting switched off without a word.
I watch three things before I move on any of this, and I break all three down here:
The first is my own behavior as a consumer, since I am not a special case and creators are consumers too. The second is what my audience does rather than what a survey says they do. The third is whether models I have not adopted are picking up speed, which is why SWR Data showing clips on the rise through 2025 got my attention.
Peaked is a different word than collapsed and I mean the first one. I still run a subscription business on OnlyFans and I am not telling anyone to dismantle something the numbers support. What I am doing is declining to add another subscription platform to my stack, Patreon included, while I build revenue that asks nobody to commit to anything recurring.
One off purchases, gifting, tipping and unlocking all ask the same small thing, which is that somebody wanted to do it once in that moment. That feels more honest about where fans are actually heading than betting the whole business on a charge they have to remember to cancel.
What ties all three together
A platform arriving with new tools and a fan switching off his rebill are the same story told from opposite ends. Both are answers to the question of what people are willing to do with their money this year, and that answer has moved more than once in the fourteen years I have been doing this. I got the model right in 2013 and the year wrong, which is a mistake that costs exactly as much as getting the model wrong does.
Do this before you close this tab
Go read the current rules of whatever platform you are considering building on next, in their words, on their site. That one habit will save you more money than almost anything else I could teach you, and it takes about twenty minutes.
Then pull your own bank statement and your own renewal numbers in the same sitting. If you are canceling subscriptions while selling one, you are holding both halves of this and you should look at them together.
P.S. Come talk it through with the rest of us inside CEO Society, which is free, and where I put the read on Patreon I deliberately left out on in this video.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in the interview are those of the guest speaker and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of SexWorkCEO or MelRose Michaels. Anything said or written is of their opinion and is not intended to malign any religion, ethnic group, club, organization, company, individual, or anyone else.
Comments